It
doesn't pay being an innovator!!
In 2000 we spent a year developing (unpaid!) a
306 page 'Business Driven Asset Management'
course book and model (below), for Engineering
Education Australia, a branch of the Institution
of Engineers, Australia (now Engineers
Australia).
I developed book and model from 'first
principles', and several topics and
relationships between topics seemed to have more
than one possibility. During the various courses
it became clear what these should be for optimal
asset management results and we changed the
model and corresponding text repeatedly and also
found an unexpected number of mistakes, some
fairly embarrassing. In 2003 we published book
and model and legally deposited it in a number
of libraries for copyright protection.

In 2007, seven years later, a highly regarded
organisation, operating in the asset management
industry, published a model, which they claim to
have developed, claim copyright for and use in
their courses and publications. This model
is alarmingly similar to my original model, as
appeared in the course book in 2000. They
include one more block, which refers to 'non
asset management solution'. Apart from this,
both models have 21 blocks, 16 with the same
text, 17 in the same position and about 25 out
of 29 relationships between the blocks the same.
It also shows the same mistakes as in my
original model and the few differences seem to
relate more to maintenance than asset
management. They affect the homogenuous balance
of the original model. (The organisation
requested that I removed their model from this
website).
The organisation claims that their model existed
in the public domain in 1991 and one of their
representatives claimed that they developed this
from the 'EUT maintenance model' by Bill
Geraerds, which is indeed in the public domain.
I reproduce this EUT model below so you can make
up your own mind whether either our (and their
similar model) shows any similarity to this
model.
We searched for any model, afer I finished
developing my course material and model in
2000, and on several occasions since and have
not been able to find anything, even faintly
resembling our model. We would be happy to
receive any such model from anybody, out of
curiosity!!